
It’s Saturday night in Staten Island and the full moon’s reflection playfully shines off New York Bay to light the unassuming Cargo CafĂ©. If you listen closely, just past the wind-battered white exterior of the bar, you can hear the voices of who will decide the fate of the Republican Party in New York City.
“If there is one thing people do at this bar, it’s talk,” said 33-year-old bartender Jason Jetson.
The one topic of conversation that can get the usually tight-lipped Staten Islanders talking is the upcoming congressional race between Democrat Michael McMahon and Republican Robert A. Straniere.
After 15 years of Republican leadership, New York’s’ 13th Congressional District - the only district in the city represented by a Republican – may be moving the Big Apple towards an entirely Democratic congressional delegation.
That would be accomplished by electing McMahon to succeed Vito Fosella Jr. (R) in the wake of his recent a drunk driving/adultery scandal.
“They are both good guys, but I’m voting for Straniere,” said Bob Carrol, 57, a lawyer living across the street from Cargo.
Carrol, who stopped in for a drink, cited Straniere’s 25 years of experience in the New York State Assembly as a reason to vote for him.
He was also concerned with the possibility of a Democrat being elected: “I don’t want a congress that is strictly Democratic, we need balance.” He wasn’t concerned about local issues, but wants a representative who was a Republican because of, what he calls, “a proactive stance towards national defense.”
Outside Cargo having a cigarette, was Mike Oates, 48, a freelance photographer and a self-proclaimed Staten Island institution – he says his family has been there for generations.
Oates, for the first time in the 30 years he’s been eligible to vote, is finally casting his first vote for McMahon, whom he says “is down to earth” and “doesn’t have any skeletons in his closet.”

McMahon, the only Democratic City Council member representing Staten Island, was the favorite at Cargo.
“Mike McMahon lives and breathes Staten Island. He has a real grasp on things – knows his district,” said Oates.
Although the people of Staten Island might disagree on who to vote for on November 4th, Oates summed up the consensus: “Staten Island is unique; people want to vote for someone that does good for the island.”